Having an issue with True-False values in my file

Hey, as the title says, I'm running into some issues when outputting my data, as the true value just goes based on the first listed input. I am pulling images from a file list, and presenting them randomly (using the $ symbol).

I have 3 stimuli/images which should be true when the input "2" is pressed, and 3 stimuli/images which should be true when the input "4" is pressed.

Is there a way to correctly match the true or false values when it is randomized from a list? Or will I have to go in manually after data collection to do this?